Is 'Causality' Holding Medicine Back?

The modern physics (quantum observation) is galvanizing me to make the assertion that causality itself is not particularly useful to us– even if it is true and important– in a health intervention setting, but instead an emphasis should be on working with correlations and creating causality.

It matters less how smiling causes happiness than the fact that it does! 

Screen Shot 2018-12-10 at 1.32.47 PM.png

Consider a quantum information perspective: Physicists provide support for retrocausal quantum theory, in which the future influences the past

In my view, a coherent field description of activity and matter conceptualizes time as more of an ocean with waves and tides than a river - the whole system is available to itself always since it is itself, but perspective means localizing of possible observation and 'causality'. The wave seems to 'happen' but it returns to a coherence that it never left, and that happening is a pattern ongoing. Each wave is unique, but is never disconnected from the substrate of happening, the ocean. So the ocean is itself and is its state always, and its future even, but each wave must express time still and know only its unique state. This is an explanation that would allow 'intuition' to exist - a linear time with causes would mean reality is cut off from itself, which I have not found compelling evidence for.

Maxwell's demon doesn't work on its deepest level because discrete variables don't exist in natural systems, discrete variables are ideas natural systems (us) have about ourSelf yet these individual ideas are not the whole truth. Even in a tamed chaos box like a computer, still the system is beyond the full accounting of the design and designers.

That old adage about correlation ≠ causation is true, but without context of the role of observers this statement loses meaning.

If a correlation drives someone to do an action, has correlation not 'caused' an action?

The truth contains our illusions, and illusions have historically been powerful causes of 'truths' in a socio-technical setting at least, so bringing perspective into science and studies of causality seems our only hope to actually arrive at useful practices and methods. 

Now of course, causality helps us mitigate problems and knowledge is power - finding causal links can also let us skip over extra processes to get at the root of effects. So it is essential to try and identify causality.

However I can't help but have a trickster twinkle in my heart about how our observations cannot be separated from our entire perspective.

We observers and researchers aren't neutral, we are coherent with the systems we study!

So the gentleman that thinks smiling is silly because the world sucks, will his smiling ever be as strong as someone who thinks the world is wonderful? His life and his studies will likely reflect his opinions, and so the only way to really 'control' for the full set of variables is to understand the perspective of oneself. Until this happens at scale, all studies will risk being reflections of local truth, rather than the full substrate of truth which contains all contradictions  - waves on the ocean, rather than the ocean itself with its waves.


AIHM Annual Advances In Biofield Medicine Pre-Conference

Toward Studying Miracles

Toward Studying Miracles

Was honored to get a scholarship to attend the AIHM Annual Advances in Biofield Medicine Pre-Conference event. Featured amazing speakers and great insight. Big takeaway was that we all need to get at least 15 minutes a day of bare feet to ground contact. Seriously. Grounding is essential for health.

the heart is a field

the heart is a field

James Oschman showed some great explainers and proposed a simple explanation of the heart that I have found much more accurate than the old way: “Maybe the heart is a field that extends throughout the universe.”

I became emotional in the closing session when Larry Dossey recounted a story of telling a terminal patient of his to, “get comfortable with living forever.” Dossey opened his heart bare to the reality of death and the immutability of the energy of which we are made. This truth-telling brought about great benefit for the patient he ‘leveled with.’ Dossey stated, and I agree, that the belief that our life ends when our brain stops firing has caused much pain. A return to having never left is needed.

Rosalyn Bruyere spoke elegantly and pointedly about the power of our healing hands and the oddness of living in air-conditioned boxes and insulated rubber shoes. She was a breath of fresh energy and got us standing up and playing with our energy, which is always appreciated!

All of the speakers were wonderful. For me it was extra great to hear and see Shamini Jain there, as I have gotten to meet her a few times and she is amazing! See her talk on the reality of the Placebo Effect and check out the Consciousness and Healing Initiative which she co-founded.

Overall this community is brave and creative enough to ask after deep questions as to what healing really is and what our bodies actually are. This is a field to watch ;)

Interestingly, much of what was said I have heard in some form from buddhist texts, such as the dharma blossom sutra. One passage breaks the mind well: The reality mark of all realities is that they are both empty and existent, and neither empty nor existent.

From my perspective, quantum physics has been a de-materializing of the scientific model of reality into informatics and computation (probability, pattern, and counting) which has let it get close to a shared mind interoperation as the buddhist texts have done (no edges to thought, consider where the reflection in a mirror exists). Now still though we need the component of the heart and meaning to make sense of this, and the courage to see ourSelf again and again.

I brought my Magic Leap One with me and showed off a quick demo I made called HoloHealing which had hand tracked ‘holograms’ and a sound wand, along with letting people use the Create app. Overall response was very good, practitioners, even the energy healer Rosalyn Bruyere who spoke really seemed to enjoy the Magic Leap One. One female practitioner even remarked after doing some painting in ML1 that she ‘didn’t get sick like in the other headsets.’ This gives me more confidence that the folks at Magic Leap are making healthy technology, as VR has a notorious and not well understood gender divide, and the fact that Magic Leap was working for the small sample of women whom used the headset I brought was great news for getting this technology beyond just games and toys and into the healing arts.


I was there to learn about the cutting edge of the biofield, but also to show the Magic Leap One to this community. My current journey is in getting the skills I need to build visualization tools for biofield research and healing. There are sensors out there, like BioWell (who was at the conference showing their cool tech) and Heartmath’s +heart unit, which can be unified into a holistic view inside of Mixed Reality headsets.

HoloHealing will continue to evolve as a meditation trainer and ‘energy cleansing’ environment based upon Pranic Healing principles of using colored light to clean the subtle bodies.

More to come on this, including software ;)

Download full notes from pre-conference as PDF (~5MB)

Read More Papers on the Biofield from with my Notes 

Holographic Healing - johnhanacek

Rick and Morty in the Wisdom Tradition

“Nobody exists on purpose, nobody belongs anywhere, everybody's going to die… come watch TV.” - Morty

In 2015 physicists used human instruments to detect gravity waves, ushering in a new era of listening to ripples in the structure of space-time itself. You will be forgiven for wondering “what does this mean?” because it is in your nature to wonder such a thing: you are a human, you are a meaning-maker.

In an age where we are presented with theories of black hole time travel and infinite universes nested inside of infinite universes we are deeply straining our abilities to connect the findings of science and its models of the cosmos with the appearance of the world that we live in daily. 

It is one thing to posit a spherical Earth, or a rotation around the sun, or that you are made of cells, these things are actually rather tangible: walk for a while and measure some shadows, get out your star charts and track a few months, and take a look at some of your skin under a microscope. Even atoms and photons can be somewhat observed. Yet the newest findings of science are not so embodied, they are not so observable. You and I are not going to fall through a black hole any time soon. Nor can we perceive the trillions of nested universes that might make up the space between the space in the atoms of our cells. 

The world we live in is the same as it ever was—except that we can tweet about it-- but the models of our cosmos have never been more exotic. “The truth,” it seems, has left us all behind. 

Enter Rick and Morty: the show that says “what if we actually could observe the multiverse, and moreover what would happen if we started wandering around between infinities?”  

Rick and Morty is loosely based around the misadventures of a fringe “scientist” Rick (in the style of Doc Brown from Back to the future) and Morty (in the style of a Marty from the same franchise, but much less girlfriended). Together they jump through the multiverse using Rick’s flying ship and his interdimensional portal gun, and one time they have to take a detour through interdimensional customs.

A new age demands a new philosophy, and in Rick and Morty I have found the most salient distillation of the findings of the modern hard sciences, and the wisdom traditions into one thesis: all meaning is local and temporary and all morality is local and temporary. Perhaps even truth itself is just a local ordering of available information. 

We are in the post-postmodern age now, when we must accept into our hearts, minds and souls that no 'outsider' is coming to help us make meaning, no one is coming to help us decide what is right and wrong, only we can make such decisions, only we make meaning.

It is our responsibility, it cannot be handed off to a god or a demon or aliens, it is only the purview of us, the finite organisms called humans on the beautiful rock called Earth. Against the nested infinities we humans stand as little droplets of order. Together we are the meaning.

Whatever images of gods we can conjure in our minds, we cannot shake the full reality that we alone find ourselves entrusted with the daily quality of our lived-in reality. Our beliefs are choices, works of art that we enshrine into our personas. If you have a belief in something specific without acknowledging the potential arbitrary-ness of belief itself then you're missing out on the real opportunity. Beliefs are real, but the believer is more real.

As the sociotechnical web of cybernetic global capitalism continues to envelop the planet and the worlds’ societies, we have crossed into a new age. Now and forward human will is a primary influence on the macro state of the earth, from climate to the features of the crust.

There is a profound dissonance in our world today. We are collectively, to use Jung’s analysis in “Man and His Symbols”,  a neurotic.

Some of us try to plant trees as others of us destroy entire forests. Some of us try to create new coral colonies as global industrial activity acidifies the oceans killing whole reefs. Some of us try to help the global poor as others continue to utilize their labor and bemoan there being “too many people.”

This is where thought and art comes in. We can imagine being an alien coming to visit our world. Before you see any of us individually, you would likely first see humanity as a superorganism. You would observe our hives glowing in the darkness. You would see the holes we dig into the earth looking for minerals. You would see vast strips of land parceled into repeating patterns.

Then you would learn gradually about the little units called “people” that make the macroscopic patterns you observed from space. You would find it fascinating and disturbing to learn of the immense dissonance in these people’s dealings with each other. They often work against each other! 

Re-enter Rick and Morty.

In one episode, Summer gets a new job and Rick begrudgingly finds himself the only one who can spare the time to drive her to work. So he gets to meet her boss, Mr. Needful, who is running a store where all the items are free; one never pays here, not with money muahahaha

“Mr. Needful” asks Rick what he desires, to which Rick replies “eh, I make my own stuff” and then immediately identifies him as the Devil, which catches the devil flat-footed. After some disinterested poking around by Rick and banter, the Devil thinks he has found the item that can tempt Rick: a microscope that reveals things beyond comprehension. Then Summer banishes Rick because she likes the feeling of community and order that the Devil, er Mr. Needful, is giving her in her chaotic teen life.

So naturally Rick comprehends the microscope and the whole scam that the Devil is running. And he manages to ruffle feathers with a strong opinion in the process.

“Does evil exist, and if so can one detect and measure it? – rhetorical question Morty the answer is yes you just have to be a genius.” – Rick

He then returns to Mr Needful’s shop with a metadevice that can detect and catalog all of the Devil’s cursed items. Along with a cure for the first customer’s curse. After a brief fight with the Devil, Summer again banishes Rick. Yet this time Rick decides to open a store across the street to remove the curses whole sale. So now the devil is merely giving away items for free and no one is paying him with their soul, instead they are paying Rick money.

Despite beating the devil, Rick is not a ‘good’ person. He professes to not care, and when people try to call that out as a bluff he leans right into it by making them feel stupid for even trying to get him to care.

Rick faces the infinity of possibilities in the universe daily and has become jaded to the very idea of good and evil. Faced with the immensity of possible experience, Rick is just along for the ride and trying to have a good time.

Yet still, Rick is a human, and no matter how he tries he cannot shake off the human nature to try and find meaning in the world. Rick’s catchphrase “wubalubadub dub” is not just nonsense, it is a cry for help.

In one episode of Rick and Morty, the entire population of the Earth gets Kroneburnged, turned into grotesque monsters, because Morty asks Rick for a love potion. The love potion is fool-proof, Rick assures… unless it comes in contact with the flu…

Naturally, Morty was already out the door before he learned of the flu caveat, headed on his way to the annual “Flu Awareness Dance.”

“Sometimes science is more art than science, Morty. A lot of people don’t get that.” – Rick

After a few failed attempts to reverse the terrible cascade of genetic mutations that Morty’s deployment of the potion evoked, Rick makes a decision: leave the reality they destroyed and find another. Luckily for them there are infinite universes, so Rick finds one where he and Morty had freshly been killed by an experiment and portals over to fill their selves’ place. 

Naturally, Morty is upset at burying his own corpse. Yet later on it gives him a clarity of vision that is unmatched by those of us who still believe that things are “meant to be” or that there is a “plan.” He is able to help Summer calm down about her own angst by scaling up the existential angst to include death, and then both of them can enjoy just being.

Rick and Morty is part of a long tradition of art which is about embracing death and infinity and finding peace in the midst of chaos. Once chaos is embraced then one is free to be oneself, and one can relinquish the desires for control to work with the desire to explore and be.


And here is where the show touches me deeply. We do not have a portal gun for our meat, only for our minds. We do not know how to touch other universes, we can only think about that and make art to play with the idea. Us as living beings only have this one Earth. The infinity for us is only theoretical. We cannot actually go to an adjacent universe. We do not have an infinite supply of worlds to go to if we mess this one up. 

Which means that we cannot actually be Rick, we can only remember the lessons of his character. Just as in the Bhagavad Gita there is Krishna who is astride reality and sees all, when a man Arjuna tries to join that stance at the edge of a battle about to take place and renounce action Krishna kindly reminds him that he is there to fight and so he must. But that the stance of infinity is there to remind him that his actions can never be boiled down to good and evil - all we ever are is that we are. 

In the Dharma blossom sutra there is a story of a great poet who writes a flowery expose about his abandonment of care for the world and material concerns, and sends it to a zen master. The zen master writes a reply: “fart fart”. The poet becomes enraged upon receiving the letter and rushes over to the monastery, only to realize in trying to confornt the Zen master that he the poet who said he knew how to let go of care had totally failed the lesson of not giving a crap. 

That is the beauty of art, and for today’s post-postmodern era I see Rick and Morty as part of the same tradition as all great wisdoms. It is an elaborate thought experiment in thresholds of absurdity and the human minds’ ability to order chaos. Rick is constantly going on adventures, and his mantra is usually “don’t think about it!” as Morty attempts to weigh morality, Rick knows that such things will get them killed in the multiverse.

Together Rick and Morty—along with Beth, Summer and Jerry—are analogs for you the viewer. Rick is boldy going where no one has gone before, but is not taking any notes and has no real agenda other than “see cool shit and do exotic drugs.” Morty is drawn in, but is trying to grasp for meaning. Yet every time Morty tries to help and impose moral order on the multiverse he finds some unintended consequence that makes his efforts pointless, or even worse.

The word “wisdom” is not an answer itself, but a pointer to a reminder: there are no clear answers, there is no clear good and evil. Anyone who is selling you some kind of clear vision of the world probably has an agenda and will profit off you buying in. Being uncertain is a power.  Dissonance is only painful if you try to remedy it - what about just letting it be and seeing how it evolves? Embracing your limits opens up infinity to you, even if just in art and mind.

Don’t be the hapless townspeople falling for Mr. Needful then relying on science Rick to cure you - be Rick and make your own stuff. But don’t copy Rick because he is a mess: Rick is fragmented because he thinks meaning is a crutch, so he just drinks himself out of caring. If you want meaning, go ahead and put it there. Just don’t forget that meaning is arbitrary or else you’ll be a brittle mess getting flustered by every challenge to your world-view. When you profess your heart and someone replies “fart, fart” you can either laugh and roll with it, or get flustered. 

Buddha, Jesus, Krishna, Rick, these god-person characters are all about offering you a challenge much more than a thing to follow. You’re supposed to take up the mantle, to assume the challenge of driving your own destiny. When Jesus says “I am the sun of God” you can repeat after him and say for yourself “I am the sun of God”. When Buddha is still in the face of fear you are invited to join that stillness. When Krishna tells you that what some call the slayer and the slain can only be called itself, you can break the spell of duality within you. When Rick says “don’t think about it” you are invited to action and to follow your curiosity. But with all these characters you are required to remember that they are art, mere thoughts of the wider picture. It’s up to you to synthesize them together. Great art in the wisdom tradition, like Rick and Morty, offers you the perceiver a unique chance: by breaking apart the personalities into characters you get to recombine them into something more real. 

Make your own stuff, see the absurdity of it all and still choose to give a shit. Because even though we get infinite art and ideas, we only get one Earth. 

"I asked my love, what do you need, to make your wild heart beat? And this, my love, he said to me wholeheartedly...Whatever makes you happy!"

- Snarky Puppy